The Duel That Never Happened

The Duel That Never Happened (HM2GEH)

Buy flags at!

N 38° 53.195', W 90° 10.959'

  • 0 check ins
  • 0 favorites
An island in the Mississippi River across from Alton was the site of one of Abraham Lincoln's less celebrated adventures.

"I don't think much of a man who is not wiser today than he was yesterday." — Abraham Lincoln

Sixteen years before the Lincoln-Douglas debates, one of our most revered presidents was challenged to a duel. On September 22, 1842, Lincoln met James Shields on an island to settle an affair of honor. What began in deadly earnest ended in laughter.

Enraged by a sarcastic article supposedly written by Lincoln, Shields demanded justice. As the person being challenged, Lincoln chose the weapons: cavalry broadswords. While waiting for the duel to begin, Lincoln used his sword to cut off a branch high overhead, making his advantage in height obvious. The issue was settled peacefully. Afterwards, Lincoln and Shields shared jokes at a tavern on the Alton levee.

"Shields is a fool as well as a liar. With him truth is out of the question; and as for getting a good, bright, passable lie out of him, you might as well try to strike a fire from a cake of tallow." —excerpt of a letter written by Mary Todd and Julia Jayne

Local newspapers harshly condemned the duel, calling for legal action against

Lincoln and Shields.

During the Civil War, Shields served as a general in the Union Army, and Lincoln spoke glowingly about his service.

The infamous article was not written by Lincoln, but by none other than his future wife, Mary Todd, and the future wife of Lyman Trumbull, a political ally.

Another island in the Mississippi played a role in a Civil War tragedy. Continue along the walking tour of Alton's historic past to learn more.
Marker ConditionNo reports yet
Date Added Thursday, May 2nd, 2019 at 5:01pm PDT -07:00
Sorry, but we don't have a picture of this historical marker yet. If you have a picture, please share it with us. It's simple to do. 1) Become a member. 2) Adopt this historical marker listing. 3) Upload the picture.
Locationbig map
UTM (WGS84 Datum)15S E 744369 N 4307964
Decimal Degrees38.88658333, -90.18265000
Degrees and Decimal MinutesN 38° 53.195', W 90° 10.959'
Degrees, Minutes and Seconds38° 53' 11.7" N, 90° 10' 57.54" W
Driving DirectionsGoogle Maps
Which side of the road?Marker is on the right when traveling East
Closest Postal AddressAt or near , ,
Alternative Maps Google Maps, MapQuest, Bing Maps, Yahoo Maps, MSR Maps, OpenCycleMap, MyTopo Maps, OpenStreetMap

Is this marker missing? Are the coordinates wrong? Do you have additional information that you would like to share with us? If so, check in.

Check Ins  check in   |    all

Have you seen this marker? If so, check in and tell us about it.

Comments 0 comments

Maintenance Issues
  1. What country is the marker located in?
  2. Is this marker part of a series?
  3. What historical period does the marker represent?
  4. What historical place does the marker represent?
  5. What type of marker is it?
  6. What class is the marker?
  7. What style is the marker?
  8. Does the marker have a number?
  9. What year was the marker erected?
  10. Who or what organization placed the marker?
  11. This marker needs at least one picture.
  12. Can this marker be seen from the road?
  13. Is the marker in the median?